An inheritance can be a blessing or a curse. Why is it a dollar given spends easier than a dollar earned? Such is human nature, or is it? Consider inoculating your estate plan from an outbreak of affluenza among your heirs.
There is an old saying, quite true, that wealth is difficult to amass but easy to squander. Many parents and grandparents come to us seeking to leave an inheritance to their loved ones without "spoiling" them. They want the fruit of their labors – the wealth they pass on – to inspire their loved ones to greater causes, and not cause that dread disease known as "affluenza."
[You likely can recognize some of the common symptoms of affluenza, too. Commonly it presents with wealth amassed over a generation being converted into depreciating consumer goods or high living in short order.]
One means to prevent or limit an outbreak of affluenza it estate planning that includes "incentive trusts." These trusts offer an opportunity to try and nudge younger generations to solid values, but as explained in a recent issue of Palisades Financial's "Sentinel," they don't always work as planned.
An incentive trust can be a beautiful tool. Through it you can specify certain "benchmarks" to be accomplished before the trust can be unlocked. For example, you could specify that your child must graduate from college, get a full-time job, and maybe even become a philanthropist before some or all of the trust funds can be paid out. Alternatively, the trust terms can be arranged such that the trust provides a sort of "matching funds" program to match the beneficiary's annual income, thus offering the incentive to work harder.
The problem is that rigid incentives may defeat your purpose. For example, some beneficiaries may not learn the intended lessons, but instead learn how to "game the system." They may work around the benchmarks either by technically meeting the requirements (but not the lessons), or they may even forge diplomas and pay-stubs to sneak their way in. More worrisome, however, is the beneficiary who does become that "good person" you hoped for, but fails to meet the rigid benchmarks of the trust (e.g., college is not for everyone).
If the trust is too rigid, it may not instill the values you had hoped, but rather force a predetermined life-plan upon the beneficiary. The key to a successful incentive trust is a keen awareness of this problem. Sometimes, the same spirit can be better utilized within a "results-oriented trust." These are a less intrusive arrangement without set benchmarks, but rather with guidelines to be pursued, a mission statement to be upheld, and the solid judgments of a trustee to carry out the spirit of the trust. The down side, of course, is that this is a more lax approach and may be easier to undermine.
It is a difficult line to walk, but if you have come to appreciate the power of using your assets to instill good values, then you also appreciate the importance of striking the proper balance. Your best course may be to consult competent counsel and share your unique situation and your goals, and then work together to design a plan with the greatest chance of success for you and your family.
Reference: Shomari Hearn, CFP®, EA. Sentinel. Palisade Hudson Financial Group LLC. (June 17, 2011) "Do Incentive Trusts Encourage Responsibility?"